People need to stop using Facebook. You're making Suckerberg richer each and every time you log in to Facebook or Instagram. 🤷🏽♀️🤷🏽♀️🤷🏽♀️ Want to see family do FaceTime if you can't meet them in person. We didn't have MySpace or Facebook before these existed and people were fine. you survived. It is time to make these techocrats broligarchy bleed 🩸 money 💰 🤑 💸
I totally agree. Deleted my account about three years ago, and it was absolutely painless. If everybody did the same thing, it would be a huge whack to Zuckerberg.
I was forced to get FB to do "social media" for my business. I had someone else do it, and as soon as possible deleted it. No way would I set one up for myself.
I deleted my account 6 years ago. Before I did, I sent out a posts with my reasons for leaving. I have continued to encourage people to get off, but people are addicted to it like nicotine. This article should get some people to break the habit!
Totally agree. I deleted mine and never looked back. I can’t stand when I hear friends giving vapid excuses like “but this is how I keep in touch with my friends”. No reason is worth supporting this vile company.
Never had an account. Fakebook always made my skin crawl. If friends and relatives can't send me pictures via another medium, I don't want to see their stupid babies.
I haven’t had a faecebook for years. After trying it awhile, back then, I saw where it was going as a place I did not like. I simply do not miss it. There are better, more personally immediate, ways of keeping in contact.
Exactly, if we were to do what we did with ABC and Disney+ they literally lost 5 billion dollars 💸 in 4 days flat. If 70% of the population were to do this on a consistent basis? We would bring them to their knees. They would forget who the orange pedophile is…. But we would have to sustain it for a year. To see the big impact on these evil greedy mofos, for it to work.
Genuine Q on this because FB and IG are not just social media anymore and haven't been for some time. For so many people these platforms are additional revenue streams, discovery platforms (many artists use them to share their work and get opps), and community builders-- I've personally just moved to a new city and feel like I miss so much of everything because I'm not regularly ln IG. If we're going to defeat suckerberg we have to offer people realistic alternatives. I'm not sure what they are but welcome people's perspectives here.
You can do face to face events on zoom and on signal... Probably more.
My friends refuse to stop using fb because "all my friends are there," they say. It's no excuse but I'll send this report to them. Maybe even on FB. I'd have to hire someone to get me off FB.. I tried and failed. FB has all the contents of my cell phone. I didn't give my permission.p
Another excellent article from Christopher Armitage, my personal favorite independent journalist/writer on any social media platform. Top notch investigating on stories that matter and are timely. Good work, Christopher. I just posted this article on my BlueSky account. Hoping to introduce more readers to Chris’ work.
Also…….don’t even get me started on Mark Zuckerberg and the deplorable human being he’s been since before his college days……he is a truly dark, wounded soul who hates women. A lot.
This is the corruption that only wads of money can afford. Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act of 1996 (47 U.S.C. § 230) should have been amended long ago. The moment an algorithm is applied against content is the instant in which a neutral communication platform becomes a publisher, subject to the laws that publishers are required to obey. Period.
Similar 'great expectations' re the evolution of the Fairness Doctrine that should have been applied to the 'emerging' satellite radio 'new world'. While FD was not a constitutional amendment, it recognized the IMPORTANCE of public ownership of airwaves & the need for local, public presentation of information AND discussion. AM radio became a cesspool & public oversight / control of the 'information highway' should have evolved akin to 2A.
USPS is not interacting with your newsletter; it is not deciding to send it on to others who might be interested. It is not even sending you newsletters from others who might share your interests or to provoke conflict. It is not an actively working to keep you on USPS. And it is not making money off you without your consent and participation.
Excellent points. So the common carrier vs publisher framing completely misses the role of algorithms, the exploitation of behavioral information etc. It’s a marketeer / propagandist then? How to rein such in yet preserve spaces like this very one where people can publish their ideas and organize people to action?
it doesn’t even need to be amended, just needs to be interpreted by a non-corrupt judge, and that is a dying species (see https://www.lawfaremedia.org/article/a-zuck-takes-on-meta). need to overhaul the judiciary. doesn’t matter what laws congresses passes when federal judges pervert their meaning and/or SCOTUS overturns them bc they interfere with corrupt system the justices have spent decades ushering in.
Yes, unfortunately the time to regulate an industry is before they can afford lobbyists. It will take a draconian measure to put that genie back in the bottle now. Both of Chuck Schumer’s daughters work for big tech, one for Meta and the other at Amazon. Im sure they are bringing an “industry perspective” to the Thanksgiving table.
Excellent newsletter Chris, and why am I not shocked. Facebook originally put guardrails on their platforms after it was revealed (similar to this scenario) that they allowed the usurpers of a coup in Myanmar to target and kill dissidents using the Meta platform.
And then MAGA came along, and now this! I’m not sure who’s worse; Trump and depraved white nationalist sycophants, or Musk, Zuckerberg, Thiel, and company.
One thing is unambiguous; these are deeply depraved, and morally bankrupt sociopaths! And that makes all of them untrustworthy, and dangerous! IMHO…:)
Marc Zuckerberg couldn’t care less as long as he’s getting richer and richer. He’s a monster like all of the rest of those billionaires who are actually no better than the average clinically diagnosed hoarders...the only difference is that it’s money they’re hoarding and Americans worship money, so their tendency to hoard is minimized, romanticized, idolized and normalized. Nobody needs more money than they can spend in 100 lifetimes and we have already seen that they’re willing to use it to subvert our democratic process, because the greedy control freaks just can help themselves.
Wonderfully researched piece. Have you thought about sending this to one or more Democratic Senators? I would also think state level law enforcement would have an interest in reading it.
They're aware, the challenge is getting them to prioritize these issues. The best way to have it go up their to do list? Have the public or donors become focused on it. At that point it impacts reelection and then they suddenly discover the political courage to act.
I try very hard not to use FB or Meta products. Zuckerberg has repeatedly admitted to now hundreds of violations of its promises to users and to Congress. It is time to turn the lights off and break it apart.
I do not say this lightly, having spent two decades in private anti trust compliance.
this response may offend some - this is just f__king unbelievable it just goes to show that money lets you get away with anything. Zuckerberg and Trump are two of a kind very sick individual's who should be hung by their testicals. Both should be put in jail and face the consequences of what I hear pedifiles face in prison. NOBODY SHOULD BE ON FACEBOOK
Such a shame that an app originally designed to share fun info and pictures with friends and family has gone so dark! Another example of how greed destroys so much! Assholes!!!
Chris, keep doing what you do! This is so important. You're the only substack (other than the local ones written by people I'm active with) that I read and interact with. You always bring so much important and relevant information to your readers and you back it up with real references, not Wikipedia! This subject of child sex trafficking is so timely and is so Trumpy and fits the whole social media profile (especially FB and Instagram as you pointed out). I shouldn't be as surprised as I am. I was never on any social media including FB and this just reassures me that I'm not totally crazy. Everyone I know (other than my husband) says it's so important to have a FB account so they can keep up with old friends, see pics of friends' kids and grandkids, and post their own stuff to brag about. Who the f---cares about any of it? If it's so important, pick up the phone or send the pictures through the mail. Or actually see these so-called "friends" and important people face to face. The oligarchs (like Zuck) who profit off these platforms ought to be held to account, but chances of that are slim to negligible.
Another brilliant exposé. I have and never will have a Facebook account: the minute back in 2006 when Facebook blew up and I was told it will own everything you post, including your photographs, I said no way!
Because of your insightful article I just deleted my instagram and WhatsApp accounts! Next is Facebook and messenger! Thank you so much for this one and for your other articles which I try to read daily! You ROCK!!!
Christopher Armitage is my favorite as well. Such great reporting, innovative, innovative and thought-provoking solutions and recommended actions and ways to fight back. He is brilliant. I’m such a fan. Thank you so much, Christopher!
A question: why cannot Zuckerberg be prosecuted for knowingly destroying evidence? And why cannot he be held accountable in some way for actively suppressing solutions? Since it is his platform, why is he not held to account for preventing safety measures? He deserves jail time.
Politicians and prosecutors are apprehensive to pursue cases against powerful and moneyed actors because it can eventually result in political opposition funded by those same powerful people. It's just a reality and unavoidable as long as we allow so much extreme wealth. Wealth is like gravity and by the time you're a billionaire you're essentially a black hole that destroys institutional equity and justice.
Thanks for the kind words and for wanting a better world, Connie 🌲🌲🌲
Thanks for your reply. Greed and vast wealth leads to people being above the law. I don’t believe you can have a just society if the wealthy cannot be held to account. We should at minimum bring back the 90% tax bracket for one…🤞
People need to stop using Facebook. You're making Suckerberg richer each and every time you log in to Facebook or Instagram. 🤷🏽♀️🤷🏽♀️🤷🏽♀️ Want to see family do FaceTime if you can't meet them in person. We didn't have MySpace or Facebook before these existed and people were fine. you survived. It is time to make these techocrats broligarchy bleed 🩸 money 💰 🤑 💸
I totally agree. Deleted my account about three years ago, and it was absolutely painless. If everybody did the same thing, it would be a huge whack to Zuckerberg.
Yup!
I was forced to get FB to do "social media" for my business. I had someone else do it, and as soon as possible deleted it. No way would I set one up for myself.
I get it…you had to do it. But good for you for deleting it as soon as you could. Awful that your employer needs to use such an evil platform.
I deleted my account 6 years ago. Before I did, I sent out a posts with my reasons for leaving. I have continued to encourage people to get off, but people are addicted to it like nicotine. This article should get some people to break the habit!
I left it many years ago too.
Totally agree. I deleted mine and never looked back. I can’t stand when I hear friends giving vapid excuses like “but this is how I keep in touch with my friends”. No reason is worth supporting this vile company.
Right Laurie. I’ve also heard the same line from friends and relatives. There’s no excuse, absolutely none.
Never had an account. Fakebook always made my skin crawl. If friends and relatives can't send me pictures via another medium, I don't want to see their stupid babies.
Lol.. about the babies. 😂🤭
Agree. Deleted Facebook when Suckerburg kissed the orange clowns ring in January. Also Amazon and anything Bozo owns. Google also sucks.
I haven’t had a faecebook for years. After trying it awhile, back then, I saw where it was going as a place I did not like. I simply do not miss it. There are better, more personally immediate, ways of keeping in contact.
Right. Facebook is not the best all end all. People need to distance themselves from it completely. They're lives would be better.
SOOOOOOOOOOOO TRUE!
Maybe the only way remaining is to stop making the oligarchs richer. To run them into the ground. This is war! Nobody seems to realize🤷♀️
Exactly, if we were to do what we did with ABC and Disney+ they literally lost 5 billion dollars 💸 in 4 days flat. If 70% of the population were to do this on a consistent basis? We would bring them to their knees. They would forget who the orange pedophile is…. But we would have to sustain it for a year. To see the big impact on these evil greedy mofos, for it to work.
Genuine Q on this because FB and IG are not just social media anymore and haven't been for some time. For so many people these platforms are additional revenue streams, discovery platforms (many artists use them to share their work and get opps), and community builders-- I've personally just moved to a new city and feel like I miss so much of everything because I'm not regularly ln IG. If we're going to defeat suckerberg we have to offer people realistic alternatives. I'm not sure what they are but welcome people's perspectives here.
You can do face to face events on zoom and on signal... Probably more.
My friends refuse to stop using fb because "all my friends are there," they say. It's no excuse but I'll send this report to them. Maybe even on FB. I'd have to hire someone to get me off FB.. I tried and failed. FB has all the contents of my cell phone. I didn't give my permission.p
Another excellent article from Christopher Armitage, my personal favorite independent journalist/writer on any social media platform. Top notch investigating on stories that matter and are timely. Good work, Christopher. I just posted this article on my BlueSky account. Hoping to introduce more readers to Chris’ work.
Also…….don’t even get me started on Mark Zuckerberg and the deplorable human being he’s been since before his college days……he is a truly dark, wounded soul who hates women. A lot.
My favorite too!
Count me in on this. He’s a Renaissance man. The best.
Same. His breadth, depth, productivity and innovation are unparalleled
ETA: Armitage’s (not Fcukerberg’s)
I think you're talking about Armitage, not Zuckerberg.
This is the corruption that only wads of money can afford. Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act of 1996 (47 U.S.C. § 230) should have been amended long ago. The moment an algorithm is applied against content is the instant in which a neutral communication platform becomes a publisher, subject to the laws that publishers are required to obey. Period.
Hear, hear!
Similar 'great expectations' re the evolution of the Fairness Doctrine that should have been applied to the 'emerging' satellite radio 'new world'. While FD was not a constitutional amendment, it recognized the IMPORTANCE of public ownership of airwaves & the need for local, public presentation of information AND discussion. AM radio became a cesspool & public oversight / control of the 'information highway' should have evolved akin to 2A.
I always thought that once you get more than X pairs of eyeballs viewing a post it should no longer fall under common carrier protection.
That said if you can send out say a million copies of a newsletter via USPS, is USPS liable for anything?
Maybe it’s the targeting that makes it different?
USPS is not interacting with your newsletter; it is not deciding to send it on to others who might be interested. It is not even sending you newsletters from others who might share your interests or to provoke conflict. It is not an actively working to keep you on USPS. And it is not making money off you without your consent and participation.
Excellent points. So the common carrier vs publisher framing completely misses the role of algorithms, the exploitation of behavioral information etc. It’s a marketeer / propagandist then? How to rein such in yet preserve spaces like this very one where people can publish their ideas and organize people to action?
it doesn’t even need to be amended, just needs to be interpreted by a non-corrupt judge, and that is a dying species (see https://www.lawfaremedia.org/article/a-zuck-takes-on-meta). need to overhaul the judiciary. doesn’t matter what laws congresses passes when federal judges pervert their meaning and/or SCOTUS overturns them bc they interfere with corrupt system the justices have spent decades ushering in.
yes! Thank you for pointing that out. They are indeed publishers not a neutral communication platform.
Yes, unfortunately the time to regulate an industry is before they can afford lobbyists. It will take a draconian measure to put that genie back in the bottle now. Both of Chuck Schumer’s daughters work for big tech, one for Meta and the other at Amazon. Im sure they are bringing an “industry perspective” to the Thanksgiving table.
Excellent newsletter Chris, and why am I not shocked. Facebook originally put guardrails on their platforms after it was revealed (similar to this scenario) that they allowed the usurpers of a coup in Myanmar to target and kill dissidents using the Meta platform.
And then MAGA came along, and now this! I’m not sure who’s worse; Trump and depraved white nationalist sycophants, or Musk, Zuckerberg, Thiel, and company.
One thing is unambiguous; these are deeply depraved, and morally bankrupt sociopaths! And that makes all of them untrustworthy, and dangerous! IMHO…:)
I agree with your diagnosis!
Marc Zuckerberg couldn’t care less as long as he’s getting richer and richer. He’s a monster like all of the rest of those billionaires who are actually no better than the average clinically diagnosed hoarders...the only difference is that it’s money they’re hoarding and Americans worship money, so their tendency to hoard is minimized, romanticized, idolized and normalized. Nobody needs more money than they can spend in 100 lifetimes and we have already seen that they’re willing to use it to subvert our democratic process, because the greedy control freaks just can help themselves.
The Smaugs, as I have seen them called.
Wonderfully researched piece. Have you thought about sending this to one or more Democratic Senators? I would also think state level law enforcement would have an interest in reading it.
They're aware, the challenge is getting them to prioritize these issues. The best way to have it go up their to do list? Have the public or donors become focused on it. At that point it impacts reelection and then they suddenly discover the political courage to act.
We need to be the ones to call our senators.
I try very hard not to use FB or Meta products. Zuckerberg has repeatedly admitted to now hundreds of violations of its promises to users and to Congress. It is time to turn the lights off and break it apart.
I do not say this lightly, having spent two decades in private anti trust compliance.
this response may offend some - this is just f__king unbelievable it just goes to show that money lets you get away with anything. Zuckerberg and Trump are two of a kind very sick individual's who should be hung by their testicals. Both should be put in jail and face the consequences of what I hear pedifiles face in prison. NOBODY SHOULD BE ON FACEBOOK
Such a shame that an app originally designed to share fun info and pictures with friends and family has gone so dark! Another example of how greed destroys so much! Assholes!!!
To be fair. It originally was a way for zuck to rate and demean girls at his school...
So true!
I have said from the beginning that Facebook would turn out to be one of the most dangerous sites on the commercial internet.
You’re amazing, Christopher. How do you come up with these stories, and how do you find the time to research them so thoroughly?!
My secret is that my entire life revolves around writing and activism!
I'll have a work life balance eventually but that is definitely not right now because it is so much fun to learn and write and share every day.
How wonderful to enjoy your career so much!
Chris, keep doing what you do! This is so important. You're the only substack (other than the local ones written by people I'm active with) that I read and interact with. You always bring so much important and relevant information to your readers and you back it up with real references, not Wikipedia! This subject of child sex trafficking is so timely and is so Trumpy and fits the whole social media profile (especially FB and Instagram as you pointed out). I shouldn't be as surprised as I am. I was never on any social media including FB and this just reassures me that I'm not totally crazy. Everyone I know (other than my husband) says it's so important to have a FB account so they can keep up with old friends, see pics of friends' kids and grandkids, and post their own stuff to brag about. Who the f---cares about any of it? If it's so important, pick up the phone or send the pictures through the mail. Or actually see these so-called "friends" and important people face to face. The oligarchs (like Zuck) who profit off these platforms ought to be held to account, but chances of that are slim to negligible.
Has Priscilla Chan weighed in on her husband prioritizing the metaverse over sex trafficking?
Thank you. She's a freaking pediatrician!
WHAT??? Then she must be a really sh*tty pediatrician!!!
Another brilliant exposé. I have and never will have a Facebook account: the minute back in 2006 when Facebook blew up and I was told it will own everything you post, including your photographs, I said no way!
Same. Didn't trust it then, and trust it much, much less now.
That's what they did! No one warned me?
JFC. If people who are reading this still use FB, please STOP! There are other ways to see cat pictures and stay in touch with your family.
Because of your insightful article I just deleted my instagram and WhatsApp accounts! Next is Facebook and messenger! Thank you so much for this one and for your other articles which I try to read daily! You ROCK!!!
Christopher Armitage is my favorite as well. Such great reporting, innovative, innovative and thought-provoking solutions and recommended actions and ways to fight back. He is brilliant. I’m such a fan. Thank you so much, Christopher!
A question: why cannot Zuckerberg be prosecuted for knowingly destroying evidence? And why cannot he be held accountable in some way for actively suppressing solutions? Since it is his platform, why is he not held to account for preventing safety measures? He deserves jail time.
Politicians and prosecutors are apprehensive to pursue cases against powerful and moneyed actors because it can eventually result in political opposition funded by those same powerful people. It's just a reality and unavoidable as long as we allow so much extreme wealth. Wealth is like gravity and by the time you're a billionaire you're essentially a black hole that destroys institutional equity and justice.
Thanks for the kind words and for wanting a better world, Connie 🌲🌲🌲
Thanks for your reply. Greed and vast wealth leads to people being above the law. I don’t believe you can have a just society if the wealthy cannot be held to account. We should at minimum bring back the 90% tax bracket for one…🤞
So if you earn or accumulate over: a million dollars, the rest is taxted! Good idea?
Ok 2illion... When is it fucking enough!?